Articles

Time Magazine 4/29/2022

APRIL 29, 2022

When the opioid addiction crisis began to surge in the U.S. about a decade ago, Dr. Medhat Mikhael spent a lot of time talking to his patients about other ways to heal pain besides opioids, from other types of medications to alternative treatments.

As a pain management specialist at MemorialCare Orange Coast Medical Center in Fountain Valley, Calif., he didn’t anticipate leaving behind the short-term use of opioids altogether, since they work so well for post-surgical pain. But he wanted to recommend a remedy that was safer and still effective.

That turned out to be acupuncture.

“Like any treatment, acupuncture doesn’t work for everyone, but the majority of my patients who have tried it have found relief,” he says. “When I started looking into studies, I discovered how much evidence there was behind this treatment, and that made me feel comfortable suggesting it as an alternative or a complement to pain medication and other treatments.”

That blend of anecdotal success, research-backed results, and growing level of openness from the medical community are all driving the popularity of acupuncture as a therapy. According to a 2021 World Health Organization report, acupuncture is the most widely used traditional medicine practice globally, and it’s gaining traction in the U.S. In 2020, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid services began covering acupuncture for the first time for chronic low back pain.

Although scientists don’t yet understand all the nuances of how it works, research indicates it can have a significant effect on certain conditions, and it shows promise for others.

What is acupuncture?

The goal of acupuncture is the same now as it was thousands of years ago when it was first developed in China: restoring balance to the body, says Kevin Menard, a sports medicine acupuncturist and Traditional Chinese Medicine practitioner in Sag Harbor, New York.

The practice is based on how energy, or qi, flows through the body along a series of channels called meridians—similar to the way nerves and vessels carry messages and blood throughout every system.

“According to Chinese medicine theory, each meridian is related to a specific organ, and placing thin needles at certain points along these meridians can effect certain changes in the body to restore homeostasis,” says Menard. The needles aren’t the type you’d use to draw blood; they’re very thin and flexible, almost like bits of wire.

Placement along the meridians is believed to cause reactions like sending more blood or lymphatic fluid to specific organs or allowing muscles to release in a way that reduces tension on joints and bones. The needles may also stimulate nerves and tweak nervous system regulation to result in a relaxation response, which relieves pain, Mikhael says.

Acupuncture is also thought to stimulate the immune system and control inflammation, Menard says, two effects that can bring benefits throughout the body. Depending on the condition or injury, relief might happen with just one treatment, but it usually takes a series of sessions, Menard says, especially if an issue is complex or chronic.

What the research says

Research on acupuncture has been extensive, and so far, robust evidence supports its effectiveness for some, but not all, conditions. According to one analysis published in February 2022 in the BMJ that analyzed more than 2,000 scientific reviews of acupuncture therapies, the science is strongest behind acupuncture’s efficacy for post-stroke aphasia; neck, shoulder, and muscle pain; fibromyalgia pain; lactation issues after delivery; lower back pain; vascular dementia symptoms; and allergy symptoms.

The National Institutes of Health (NIH) finds that acupuncture for pain relief tends to have the most evidence, especially for conditions that have become chronic like osteoarthritis and lower back pain, as well as tension headaches. A review of 11 clinical trials also suggests that acupuncture may help with symptoms associated with cancer treatment, the NIH notes.

That’s been a booming area of interest for the field, says Sarah Weaver, an acupuncturist and massage therapist at Northwestern Health Sciences University in Minnesota, which focuses on integrative health professions, such as acupuncture, chiropractic, and Traditional Chinese Medicine. For cancer patients, sessions there can focus on reducing nausea, numbness, and tingling (called neuropathy), brain fog, low appetite, acute and chronic pain, and mood challenges that come with cancer care.

“Often, people with cancer want to add complementary treatment that doesn’t affect their chemotherapy or radiation, and that’s where an option like acupuncture can be helpful,” she says. “It’s the reason more healthcare systems are bringing this treatment into their integrative care options.”

What’s next in the field

Acupuncture is far from a proven and accepted therapy for most conditions—even for the ones that show promise. That’s in part because the studies that support it are sometimes not high quality, and the field lacks standardized protocols that would better allow it to be scientifically evaluated, the recent WHO report finds.

For instance, one 2016 research review analyzed studies looking at acupuncture for substance abuse and addiction. Among the 83 research articles included in the review, the researchers found substantial variations in study quality, acupuncture frequency, how long needles were left in the body during treatment, which points along the meridians were used, and other potentially important factors. That made it difficult to evaluate how effective the acupuncture really was. The field also lacks clear terminology and universally accepted agreement about the location of acupuncture points, researchers argue.

Issues like these will have to be resolved to get more clarity, and to earn recommendations from reputable organizations in the future. International experts in the field are pushing to make clinical trials more rigorous in order to prove acupuncture’s utility for patient care and to help providers adopt the best practices as more benefits become clear.

Some potential directions for future studies include studying how acupuncture may affect hormonal regulation, such as alleviating hot flashes in menopause or addressing menstrual irregularity. Research indicates that the practice can boost estrogen and other hormones, and acupuncture for gynecological issues is becoming more popular, says Menard. Some researchers are also focused on studying acupuncture’s impact on fertility; some small, preliminary studies indicate its use may be linked to getting pregnant sooner and having better outcomes from IVF treatments.

Acupuncture for mental health issues like depression and anxiety is another major research direction, especially in terms of how these issues affect overall health. For example, chronic pain has often been linked to depressive symptoms, so researchers are looking at whether acupuncture can address both: a person’s pain and their depression. Researchers are hopeful. A study published in 2020 in the journal Frontiers in Neurology found that people with migraines who did acupuncture treatments had a lower risk of depression and anxiety, and tended to use medical services less often, compared to migraine patients who didn’t do acupuncture.

As the evidence base expands, acupuncture will likely continue to grow in popularity. Although acupuncture has been used for centuries, only in the past decade has there been a seismic shift in acceptance by both Western medical doctors and patients, Menard says. Ongoing research efforts and increased interest from health systems means that the treatment may be part of more conversations like Mikhael had with his patients.

“At the end of the day, doctors want their patients to feel better, and many people are looking for non-pharmaceutical paths for wellness,” Menard says. “Depending on the condition, those little needles can make a huge impact.”

Ranch Stevi

Events

Pain Management Class

Blog

Spring is Here! Wake Up and Smell the Coffee

What exactly is time? It can be viewed as a linear phenomenon, one that stretches infinitely back into the past and infinitely forward into the future.  Or it can be viewed as cyclical, a series of repeating patterns defined by the seasons.  The latter is the view taken by many traditional cultures, including the ancient Chinese.  The Chinese are adept at recognizing cyclical patterns in nature. They view themselves and their activities as part of these patterns and seek to live in accord with them. Generations of human lives have refined the understanding that Spring gives birth, summer grows, autumn gathers, and winter stores. 

Traditional agricultural societies are based on this understanding of time and seasonal change.  But modern society and its technology have separated many humans from the cycles of nature. Fortunately, the ancient Chinese have studied the cyclical nature of time and its impact on humans in great detail. There is much to be learned from these observations if one recognizes that humans are subject to the same principles of cyclical time that govern all natural phenomena.

Mostly it is common sense to live in harmony with the seasons.  We wear heavy clothing and eat warm food in winter, dress lightly and eat more salads and fruits foods in summer. The tricky part is adjusting the body and mind during the transitions between seasons.  The transition between winter and spring is particularly difficult for humans both physically and emotionally.  Even as the seeds of springtime activity and desires are stirring, the environment remains cold and harsh, and the warmth of home beckons.  Yet, cabin fever often sets in at the end of winter, and we yearn for activity and sunlight. These conflicting urges can lead to health issues as the body and mind awaken from their metaphorical slumber.

Let’s examine some common health problems that arise in the transition from winter to spring.  Spring is associated with the liver organ in Chinese medicine. The healthy liver is like a sapling: rapidly growing up and out, yet flexible enough to deal with obstructions and difficulties.  Coming out of winter, the body must awaken from its period of dormancy, stillness, and contemplation.  It must be reborn into the world of activity, movement, and service.

A person with a weak liver may have trouble adjusting to Spring.  In these cases, one may feel groggy and stiff.  The liver blood animates the eyes, so vision problems such as blurry vision, floaters, or dry and itchy eyes often arise in spring.  The liver also controls the tendons and ligaments, so stiff and painful joints are also common in spring.

Others may have overactive livers. These people are likely to suffer from headaches and hypertension as reactivated liver energy rises excessively. Excessive liver energy may also lead to digestive problems such as bloating, gas, and pain. The liver regulates the energy of the entire body and works closely with the stomach and intestines to ensure smooth movement of the digestion. An overactive liver often impairs digestive function.

Still others may have stagnant or depressed liver energy. In addition to regulating the body’s energy, it also regulates the emotions.  A healthy liver allows the mind to experience emotions appropriately and then move on to the next feeling. A stagnant liver may cause us to become stuck in a certain emotion. Anger, frustration, and irritability are the sensitive emotions of the Liver, so they often arise in spring.

How do we ease these season physical and emotional challenges? First, be aware of your place in cyclical time. Are we in the deep stillness of winter, or at the end of winter when the seeds of activity are stirring, or is it warming into spring already? The Chinese view the liver as guiding us towards our destiny and true purpose. As spring approaches it is time to wake up, smell the coffee, make to do lists, and start preparing and planning. A healthy liver establishes clear purpose, intention, and perseverance for attaining goals.

Physically, it is time to move. But be cautious when beginning to be more active.  Gentle stretching and low impact exercise are the best choices to avoid tendon, ligament and joint problems. Once the body has warmed up and become supple it can withstand more rigorous exercise and activity.

Chinese diet therapy states that warm and cooked foods should make up most of our diet year round.  However, a slight increase in fresh raw greens and sprouts is a good way the stimulate the liver for renewal. Also, the Liver will benefit from not having to process fried, rich, and spicy foods, which can impair its function.

Emotionally, spring is an ideal time to let go of negative emotions and grudges. It is a season of great change, which while difficult, offers great opportunity. Try something new, clean out your closet. Make physical and psychic space for new experiences and relationships to come into your life. So do yourself a favor. When the first warm day comes, open the window wide, breath deeply the crisp fresh air and recall exactly where you are in time.

snow, new zealand, snowdrift-4066640.jpg

Survive and Thrive in the Covid Era Part One: Hunkering Down

 *Note: This essay was originally posted in Dec. 2020

Why do we hunker down? Well, to ride out the storm out, to live to fight another day, right? Is the soldier who charges forward against all odds heroic or foolish? We hunker down to survive. Sometimes we need to check the damage done, lick our wounds, and then begin to garner our resources to prepare for our inevitable return to the full light of day.  

This exact human tendency to move inward to protect and collect oneself occurs every autumn as part of the cyclical flow of the time. The pandemic has thrown us all off balance by requiring an extreme inward movement, including social and physical distancing.  This behavior is a normal reptilian brain survival response, but normally mortal threats pass quickly. Sadly, the new normal has been like a prolonged Autumn since Spring!

But don’t worry, the ancient Chinese have a “mind” dedicated to survival. More to the point, we all have an aspect of the mind that processes basic instincts, especially the survival instinct. This part of “mind” seeks food, clothing, shelter, warmth, and safety from danger. Brain scientists call it the amygdala, or reptilian brain. The ancient Chinese called it the Po, or “corporeal soul”. This is precisely the mental tool to call upon in times of crisis or danger like a pandemic.

True enough, the Po has selfish goals and lacks empathy. Yes, it may lead us to conflict, oppression and violence if left unchecked. We have seen the reptilian brain do some ugly things.  That said, survival of a society starts with an individual’s will to survive. In order to survive as a group, we will also need those parts of the brain that provide empathy, cooperation, and intelligence. 

But don’t worry, the ancient Chinese have a “mind” for that too. In fact, he ancient Chinese understanding of mind is composed of five parts each with distinct functions:

The Shen, or spirit, leads the five minds as consciousness and thought.

The Yi, or intellect, processes memory and analysis.

The Po, or corporeal soul, reacts with primal instincts, most notably the instinct to survive.

The Zhi, or will, allows our will to survive and ambitions.

The Hun, or ethereal soul provides direction and purpose. 

Each of these aspects of mind will be examined in this series of articles, highlighting their roles in our personal health and collective well-being. 

We will start with the most primordial mind, the Po. The Po is a lower level of intelligence.  Rather than thinking, it simply reacts to threat. Survival is a very real threat today with the Covid death toll in the U.S. at over 245,00 and rising at a record rate.  We are also struggling for economic, social and emotional survival. Many events are beyond our control, but the Po can help us survive and thrive through these challenges. Ever cautious and vigilant, the Po urges us to retreat internally when we feel threatened, like a turtle retreating into its shell for protection. 

The inward tendency of the Po corresponds to Autumn, the time of harvesting and gathering.  Humans naturally gather and process their resources in the Fall and plan how to dole them out over the lean months ahead. Though limiting, this mindset plays a crucial role for survival, both seasonally and during this metaphorical Autumn of a pandemic confinement. 

The Po is associated with the Lung.  Like these organs, the Po functions as a connection between the internal and external worlds. The Lung functional system includes the lung itself as well as the skin. It is known as the delicate organ, due to its delicate tissues that are exposed to the outside world through respiration. It is also most responsible for our immune function, by virtue of its control of the opening and closing of pores and the oxygenation of blood.  

The Lung is our first line of defense against viruses, bacteria, and airborne pollution. It  tends to accumulate phlegm to fight infection, or as an auto-immune response to an allergen, or as asthma.  A healthy lung uses the immune cells in phlegm to kill infection and then disperse the phlegm.  But often phlegm persists after infection is gone or is generated by allergies, asthma, and even poor diet. If this becomes the case, you are clearly at greater risk for infection and a severe course of disease if infected by Covid-19.

Scary, yes.  Fortunately acupuncture and herbs can both strengthen the lung to prevent infection and also to treat acute infection when it occurs. The Chinese science of treating epidemic disease with herbs to kill viruses, reduce fever, and stop cough continues as a valuable complement in China and worldwide. Obviously the Acupuncture Clinic of Missoula does not treat active infections in the clinic, but herbal formulas are dispensed to be taken as needed along with conventional therapies to improve outcomes. 

While acupuncture and herbal medicine work best together, herbal therapy alone is a powerful tool to boost your immune system and to keep on hand in the event of infection. It is important to note that an herbal consult is required in order to prescribe and dispense the proper herbal formula. 

Acupuncture has a strong effect on bronchitis and cough.  In fact, Autumn is an ideal time to strengthen the Lung to prevent bronchitis and stop coughing with acupuncture. The Lung tends to dry and wants to be wet. In Autumn dryness can worsen this tendency, leading to chronic cough, so those that tend to Lung dryness.

These suggestions are concrete measures to improve your body’s ability to first avoid infection by improving your immunity, and to be prepared to treat yourself instantly should you become infected. The dangers are real people. But our drive will always be to survive first.  The Po, or corporeal soul, is always on point. Keep it as sharp as possible.